Zilvia.net Forums | Nissan 240SX (Silvia) and Z (Fairlady) Car Forum

Zilvia.net Forums | Nissan 240SX (Silvia) and Z (Fairlady) Car Forum (#/f/index.php)
-   S Chassis (#/f/forumdisplay.php?f=97)
-   -   So..I put OEM SR20DE 9.5:1 pistons in my SR20DET... (#/f/showthread.php?t=562890)

kovert240sx 04-23-2014 11:39 AM

So..I put OEM SR20DE 9.5:1 pistons in my SR20DET...
 
So to be honest..It wasn't intentional, but interesting that it kinda worked anyway.

A couple years back i had a machine shop do the assembly on a rebuild and they said they could also order the factory pistons.

Without thinking what that meant, I went ahead with it. ( I intended to put factory DET pistons in it ).


After the engine was complete I had it dyno tuned on a mustang dyno with the following:

Stock rods
Stock injectors
Stock fuel system aside from Z32 filter / walbro pump, also stock fuel pressure.
Stock intake manifold.
Nistune
HKS GT2510
256/256 cams
Tubular bottom mount manifold w/ full exhaust
91 octane gas @ 17psi

Results:

366whp / 310ft lbs tq

I was maxing out the injectors so the low boost = low tq.

I ended up having my drain plug back itself out on the dyno that day, lost all oil and killed the turbo.

fast forward 2 years: at some point during a injector upgrade/turbo swap, or maybe even the same day I killed the turbo..my ( DET ) piston rings are toast.

Pulled the head yesterday and discovered my mistake from the build.

Even though it wasn't intentional, i figured I'd share anyway as I've never heard of it being attempted.

jr_ss 04-23-2014 11:43 AM

People put high comp pistons in all the time, perhaps not our motors, but it's not unheard of.

kovert240sx 04-23-2014 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr_ss (Post 5616248)
People put high comp pistons in all the time, perhaps not our motors, but it's not unheard of.

Obviously, but I had never heard of anyone using SR20DE oem pistons in a DET.

hobbs 04-23-2014 11:54 AM

Not like the B/P chassis guys have been putting turbos on their DEs for the last 20 years. You must be the first one ever to do this.

kovert240sx 04-23-2014 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hobbs (Post 5616265)
Not like the B/P chassis guys have been putting turbos on their DEs for the last 20 years. You must be the first one ever to do this.

holy shit, did you even read my last comment?

hobbs 04-23-2014 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kovert240sx (Post 5616268)
holy shit, did you even read my last comment?

I did but can't seem to care. Again, putting 9:5:1 compression pistons in any SR20 has been done for the last 20 years, you've done something that thousands of other people have done, wooo!

kovert240sx 04-23-2014 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hobbs (Post 5616281)
I did but can't seem to care. Again, putting 9:5:1 compression pistons in any SR20 has been done for the last 20 years, you've done something that thousands of other people have done, wooo!

You can't seem to care that you're avoiding my point all together?

Lets recap for the dunce: OEM high comp NA pistons in a DET - I've yet to see done once, let alone THOUSANDS of times.
:picardfp:

hobbs 04-23-2014 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kovert240sx (Post 5616284)
Lets recap for the dunce

I sure am, although you can't seem to grasp the concept that 9:5:1 is the same CR whether it be in a DET block or DE block and will make the same power regardless which block it is in. So yes, your DET with DE pistons will make the same power as a DE with DE pistons with the same mods.

The fact that DET's have oil squirters and sodium filled exhaust valves does not affect the compression radios and thus will not affect the power output like a higher compression would.

But since you really want to have the title of being the first one of putting DE pistons in a DET, go for it, I won't tell anyone you're 20 years late to the party.

kovert240sx 04-23-2014 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hobbs (Post 5616301)
I sure am, although you can't seem to grasp the concept that 9:5:1 is the same CR whether it be in a DET block or DE block and will make the same power regardless which block it is in. So yes, your DET with DE pistons will make the same power as a DE with DE pistons with the same mods.

The fact that DET's have oil squirters and sodium filled exhaust valves does not affect the compression radios and thus will not affect the power output like a higher compression would.

But since you really want to have the title of being the first one of putting DE pistons in a DET, go for it, I won't tell anyone you're 20 years late to the party.

I could care less about a title, or being the "first". My intention wasn't to turn this into some cool guy pissing contest.

kruked 04-25-2014 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kovert240sx (Post 5616329)
I could care less about a title, or being the "first". My intention wasn't to turn this into some cool guy pissing contest.

Can I join the pissing contest? I like setting records.

Dboyizmlg 04-25-2014 01:28 PM

Wait a second... You made 366whp on a mustang dyno with STOCK INJECTORS!?
I find that very hard to believe!

5280VertDET 04-25-2014 01:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dboyizmlg (Post 5618230)
Wait a second... You made 366whp on a mustang dyno with STOCK INJECTORS!?
I find that very hard to believe!

Maybe 266? Sounds more likely. On my FWD JDM SR20DET with 370s & T25 I made 249...

RalliartRsX 04-25-2014 01:56 PM

Those stock injectors (assuming 370cc) run out of physical flow around 250WHP.

They are not PHYSICALLY capable of 366WHP

And also, how the hell are you making more than 300WHP on a T25 based turbo??

Da Fuq?!?! I think Hobbs not caring is the fact that he also smells bullshit in your storyline........... :rolleyes:

Dboyizmlg 04-25-2014 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RalliartRsX (Post 5618255)
Those stock injectors (assuming 370cc) run out of physical flow around 250WHP.

They are not PHYSICALLY capable of 366WHP

And also, how the hell are you making more than 300WHP on a T25 based turbo??

Da Fuq?!?! I think Hobbs not caring is the fact that he also smells bullshit in your storyline........... :rolleyes:

^^ my point exactly.

Frank_Jaeger 04-25-2014 02:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dboyizmlg (Post 5618230)
Wait a second... You made 366whp on a mustang dyno with STOCK INJECTORS!?
I find that very hard to believe!

It doesn't say what injectors he has, only that he's maxing them out. Reading comprehension.

EDIT: Nevermind I fail. It definitely says stock injectors. DE Pistons are magic.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqqB8NjcKJU

hobbs 04-25-2014 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RalliartRsX (Post 5618255)
Those stock injectors (assuming 370cc) run out of physical flow around 250WHP.

They are not PHYSICALLY capable of 366WHP

And also, how the hell are you making more than 300WHP on a T25 based turbo??

Da Fuq?!?! I think Hobbs not caring is the fact that he also smells bullshit in your storyline........... :rolleyes:

It was more the fact that this guy thinks hes the first one to do a 9:5:1 build, his mod list is even more a joke when you look at the posted numbers.

Def 04-25-2014 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RalliartRsX (Post 5618255)
Those stock injectors (assuming 370cc) run out of physical flow around 250WHP.

They are not PHYSICALLY capable of 366WHP

And also, how the hell are you making more than 300WHP on a T25 based turbo??

Da Fuq?!?! I think Hobbs not caring is the fact that he also smells bullshit in your storyline........... :rolleyes:

Injectors obviously make this BS. You will be close to maxing out 550 cc injectors at that power level on E10.

But the HKS GT2510 is essentially a stock S14/S15 'T28' aka GT2560R. It can do 300 rwhp with the wick turned up, even on stock cams.

A GT2871R is still a "T25 based turbo" and it'll do over 400 rwhp when pushed really hard.

hobbs 04-25-2014 04:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Def (Post 5618354)
A GT2871R is still a "T25 based turbo" and it'll do over 400 rwhp when pushed really hard.

Actually it's not, it's a T2 biased turbo, the T2 housing was around before the T25 series came out. Just because it can be made to fit a T2 housing does not mean anything, considering the T25 and GT2871R have very little in common other than it can be mated to the same exhaust housing flange.

RalliartRsX 04-25-2014 05:09 PM

I see what both Hobbs and Def are saying

Def, Me as well as yourself know if we look at the compressor maps for what is essentially a glorified T28, it would refute his statements IMMEDIATELY..........but since people (especially the original poster) on here have NO EFFING CLUE on what those are, I kept it simple for the masses :)

For the masses: At 366WHP, that is 400+ Crank HP, and not many "T2" framed turbos are capable of that type of flow, ESPECIALLY this turbo.

This scenario right here is why Zilvia is such a shit show.........

zerodameaon 04-25-2014 08:01 PM

Someone got caught with their hand in the bullshit jar.

!Zar! 04-25-2014 09:26 PM

I heard we were whipping out dicks?

cotbu 04-25-2014 10:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !Zar! (Post 5618567)
I heard we were whipping out dicks?

Is it that time of the year already!
Dicks out, In April!

Dboyizmlg 04-26-2014 12:56 AM

His entire mod list is screwed up!

OP there is no way you can make those numbers on a MUSTANG DYNO with the list you posted.

Why did you make this thread!?
Troll? Or are you really lacking some knowledge?

kovert240sx 04-26-2014 12:58 AM

First of all, Hobbs and def and rally whatever the fuck.. You guys are fucking idiots. Period.

Injectors are rated based on fuel pressure. Increasing that pressure increases flow. Any dip ship knows this. So to claim that 370s are not capable of flowing whatever bullshit number you pulled out of your ass proves my first point.

Second, whichever one of you idiots claimed t2 based turbos cant make 400hp. FYI t25 and t28 are BOTH t2 turbos!

Look at a fucking compressor map...pretty simple to figure out you have no fucking clue what your talking about.

If you want to have fun by jumping all over anyone with a low post count, be my guest, but at least have a slight clue what your saying first.

And to reiterate my reason for posting..this car was running oem sr20de pistons. I can't seem to get that across, OEM DE 9.5:1 Pistons!

Obviously you can get a plethora of aftermarket high comp pistons, my point was that I had never heard of these being used in a DET! And wanted to share my results, fuck me for trying to share.

I could give a fuck less if you guys thinking I'm bullshitting, It's no wonder why I stayed on FA before it went to shit.

You fuckin drift douches have bumped your heads too much, I've got dyno sheets and time slips to prove my claims, you guys can keep your bs knowledge and enjoy your group fuck session spewing with stupidity.

kovert240sx 04-26-2014 01:24 AM

And to clarify, I know that 366 sounds high for stock fuel pressure as my old car I had to crank it to supply enough fuel for 362whp. That was also the point of my post. Unless my 370s were remand in Japan and my kvalue ( calculated for 370/z32 maf ) magically worked with 11.5 afrs they are stock 370s and my hunch is the jump from 8.5 to 9.5 comp really makes that big of a difference in expected hp.

Also, my hks turbo was purchased used with its ID plate unreadable, I bought it as a 2510 but it obviously could have been any variation of a hks t2 flanged/ internally gated turbo.

zerodameaon 04-26-2014 01:51 AM

I just ran the numbers, you mean to tell me you are running 180 psi for your fuel pressure? Because that is what your above post about more psi = more power just said. That is at 90% duty cycle, at 100% duty cycle you would still be looking at 145 psi. Fun fact, 180 psi is about half way to the pressures found in a top fuel dragster fuel system, I am sure your SR20 is demanding that.

kovert240sx 04-26-2014 02:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zerodameaon (Post 5618702)
I just ran the numbers, you mean to tell me you are running 180 psi for your fuel pressure? Because that is what your above post about more psi = more power just said. That is at 90% duty cycle, at 100% duty cycle you would still be looking at 145 psi. Fun fact, 180 psi is about half way to the pressures found in a top fuel dragster fuel system, I am sure your SR20 is demanding that.

Lol!
Lets ignore that most nissan 370s have been known to flow closer to 415cc..


[email protected] = [email protected]

Calculation for required cc for 380bhp is 442cc at 0.60 bsfc / 80psi


Not sure where you're getting this nonsense, but you can sit down now.

zerodameaon 04-26-2014 02:25 AM

2 Attachment(s)
A very bad calculator which I forgot was not very accurate. Anyways I have moved on to two others and those ones agree your numbers still fall short. You would still need to be running 120+ psi to get your power with those injectors. Attached are my sources this time, where is yours? Or is that what your power numbers were, just guesstimates?


Disclaimer, I did mess up those numbers but it was not going to benefit you any if I corrected them. I did not see that the HP numbers on those calculators are engine HP and not wheel.


EDIT: Yes fuck you for sharing. lol Anyways it would have been all cool and no one would have torn your thread to bits if you had just not lied about what you really have going on. People would have thought it was a good cheap way to get a few HP but when you claimed unicorns it was all going to go to hell.

kovert240sx 04-26-2014 02:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zerodameaon (Post 5618716)
A very bad calculator which I forgot was not very accurate. Anyways I have moved on to two others and those ones agree your numbers still fall short. You would still need to be running 120+ psi to get your power with those injectors. Attached are my sources this time, where is yours? Or is that what your power numbers were, just guesstimates?


Disclaimer, I did mess up those numbers but it was not going to benefit you any if I corrected them. I did not see that the HP numbers on those calculators are engine HP and not wheel.

Hey Genius, Your calculators are using 43.5 as fuel pressure.

I think you're done here, Mr. top fuel.

Run along.
http://www.rceng.com/technical.aspx

zerodameaon 04-26-2014 03:01 AM

4 Attachment(s)
Oh I am not through with you yet, you are a straight up fucking moron, if you had a 640cc injector at 43.5 and you pumped it up to 120psi you would be looking at over 1000CC.

That is the required static flow rate, now if you go to the bottom of the page you get a nice little fuel flow calculator, where you can put in the old PSI and new PSI along with the old injector flow rate and it calculates you out a nice new flow rate at the higher PSI.

Now please tell me where I fucked up this time. Your calculator gives me almost the same info... shocking


For the sake of consistency I used 366 as the crank HP and 90% duty cycle.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:14 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
vB.Sponsors
Copyright © 1998 - 2019, Zilvia.net™