SR20DET(s14) vs. RB25DET
 

SR20DET(s14 version) vs. RB25DET .......for price and performance.....best deal

s14 IMO because it's cheaper out the door. :bow:

i voted for rb.. but iono maybe b/c its a skyline motor. haha.. but anyways, after considering options..
s14SR and RB25 cost about the same for a front clip. however, RB will cost more to drop in since it needs custom mounts and driveshaft, etc.

Wiring will be a little different for both. RB probably has the ability to handle more boost SAFELY since its spread through six cylinders compared to four thus making more power. But depends on how you build up each motor. If you stroke the s14sr to 2.2L than you might have something.

Price of parts is quite different as well. It will cost MORE to buy RB parts since they are rarer and SR parts are so popular that most of them are in stock in the US. also considering, you have to pay for more stuff since its six cylinders (ie. 6 forged pistons comapred to 4, 6 injectors to 4, etc.) higher price parts for the RB since the demand isn't as high as SR parts. etc.

Both can make great power. I think the S14 sr is more bang for the buck compared to the RB unless you have tons of money and money isn't really an issue and you're going for more power and more bling factor.

RB! cause skyline motors are sick. and since I can't afford a skyline, I'll take the motor instead. Why would you want an aneamic 4 cylinder anyways. Everyone knows you need a inline 6 to be icey hot! You can't drift on a 4 cylinder either, it's too week! Skyline power all the way! Bitches like it too when I tell them I have an icey hot skyline motor.

i hope you are joking ^^

authough the RB25 is a sweet motor... the cost of putting it in your car and having it run is too much

If I was going to spend the kind of money it takes to put in an rb25, I'd save some more until I could put in a rb26dett. Bigger injectors, plenty of turbo, couple upgrades net 400whp. It'd probably cost like $9k to get it running at that level, probably close to what an sr or rb25 would cost for the same power level, but with better drivability (than sr20 mainly).



But what do I know, I have a ca.

I would go KA-t. SR or RB is just JDM style right now. Not really the best if you consider you going have to upgrade and rebuild all the stuff if you want to run 300+ HP anyways. Just me 2cent.

Who saids you need to rebuild an SR or Rb25det to get 300+ hp? Having driven a couple of KA24DETs/Sr20dets and owning an Rb25det, the Rb25 put the other two motors to shame (a lil exaggerated :) ) The response and smoothness of an Rb25 is just amazing. But for the hazzles, I would have stuck with the KA24DE and turbo it . And no---SR and Rb is not the "JDM style", its just a matter of preferences. Some like motors that are turboed from the factory and some like straight six with turbos.

I'd say more bang for the buck - Ka with standalone a few mods ( like injectors, spark, ignition, and such and of course turbo preping) and turbo upgrade.

I voted s14sr, I think that it's the better choice for me. I'm looking for a smooth hi(er) revving linier engine with about 250hp something very well balanced. Maybe later I will up hp. For now I have a KA, and don't want to jump into an over powered car (over powered for me that is). I know this is going to sound strange to some of you, but I want an engine with less tq than hp.

you should go with go with the b or k serious then HAHA :ghey:

You don't have to rebuild to get that power. But You should rebuild it to get it bullet proof. Even a stock Ka can handle 400+ hp, but I doubt it will last if you drift/touge with the car, so that power is not really "useful" power. You got this choices if you want big power that is actually safe. KA rebuild / the SR rebuild / RB with a fat price tag on parts and install. Of course, KA rebuild is the cheapest for the best reliability, + if you get a ref ticket you are much easier to deal with. You can just unbolt the turbo parts. Anyways like I said, just my 2 pennies.

Actually this Poll should be between the Sr and the RB20DET
There both the same displacement
Personally i would say its personal taste but i chose the RB20DET
The RB20DET front clip is cheaper than buying a motorset of a SR
Stock for stock they have the same power but the power band on the RB is wider
The RB25DET is in another class compared to the SR

hahaha and that's why it's the sr is the most common motor in drifting.

^ i think that was sarcasm. Anyway, for big power, the RB is definitely the way to go, however you pay to play,and therefore it is more expensive. I think for the money, the KA-t is the only way to go. Use mostly (if not all) usdm parts (i nkow that may not sond too 'cool') if you break stuff. All u need is injectors, SAFCII, the usual mani/dp/wg/bov/turbo and an i/c and you only have to push about 8psi and you're netting around 230whp with more tq than you'd need. They have awesome power bands when turbo'd as opposed to SRs. And to whoever said stroke the SR to 2.2, that runs no less than like 7k. So thats quite a bit of money, especially considering you're still less displacement than you started with

Everyone's got SR. IMO they are over rated (I have one).

KA-T has higher displacment, so if i were to start my car over i would defently go withthe Ka-T. It's some what cheaper too. If i had the deep pockets, RB25 is the way to go. Ironblock inline 6... common now.

Go with the Boostdesign rebuilt KA engine. Or rebuild one urself at a local shop. Won't run you more than 3g. Now turbo it for another 2-3g. Go standalone and tune it for another 1-2g. For around 6-8g you got a reliable engine that can run 400-500hp all day. Compare that to a SR swap that would easily run you 4-5g with all the replacement parts and not been all that reliable and only lay down 200-250hp. If you want more power say 300+ hp you got to replace injector, turbo, intercooler, get tuning devise. And if you want even more 400-500, then you need head work, gasket, etc. That easily gets to above 8g without a fully built motor from the bottom end up.

" All engines are shit if you don't rebuild them."

Enough said.

why must we continue to have these SAME threads over and over...:rolleyes:

bottom line is, its all personal preferrence and what your goals for the car are. There's pros and cons for ka's, sr's, and rb's. There is no, i repeat, THERE IS NO engine that is necessarily "better" than the other. For goodness sake....

you don't know much about RB's do you? You do not even have to rebuild a RB25 to get to over 300 hp( not to mention the fact the engine is good for 500hp on stock internals) with bolt ons. I.E. Greddy intake manifold, Q45 throttle body, FMIC and a SAFC , dyno tune it and I gurantee you will squeeze just over 300 HP at 9lbs of boost on stock internals. No reliability issues.

That I mean mostly SR. RB I know handles 400+ hp without having to open the engine.